COI Basics
David Bunch
Property owners used to worry about wind, hail, and wildfires.
Now the quiet killer is the documentation gap.
Premiums have doubled
A Yield PRO analysis shows average multifamily insurance premiums are roughly twice their 2021 level, including a 45 percent jump from 2023 to 2024. A Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis survey reports deductibles up 700 percent over the same period. Carriers are not saying buildings have suddenly become more combustible. They are saying: “Show us tamper‑proof evidence that you mitigated risk, or pay the uncertainty tax.”
The hidden invoice nobody budgets for
Staff weeks stitching together PDFs and spreadsheets — every missing timestamp must be recreated before renewal or litigation.
Legal hold notices when a resident screenshot goes viral — emails, texts, and PMS notes enter discovery, driving five‑figure defense bills even if you win.
8–12 percent “documentation load” added at renewal — underwriters apply a pricing cushion when evidence is thin (underwriter roundtable, May 2025).
Habitability verdict inflation — typical awards have climbed from $15–25 k to $75–100 k per plaintiff in the past five years.
Why PDFs and spreadsheets will not survive the next subpoena
Editable files invite accusations of back‑dating.
Screenshots lack the metadata courts and carriers now request.
Resident communication is scattered across SMS, portals, and email—the first plaintiff with a complete thread wins the narrative.
The Defensibility Layer: three pipes, one goal
Predict — live weather, sensor, and resident‑message streams flag hazards before they become claims.
Prove — every mitigation step is time‑stamped in an append‑only, hash‑sealed log; no retro edits, no lost photos.
Publish — export that log in carrier‑ready JSON/SOV so underwriters ingest proof instead of assumptions.
When evidence moves at data‑feed speed, renewal shifts from persuasion to exchange. Loss‑ratio relief, lower contingencies, and faster claim resolution follow.
Your next steps
Schedule a 20‑minute review with our team to benchmark your current “proof latency” and outline a pilot.
More From the Blog
COI Basics
Jun 10, 2026
The Coverage Gap Time Bomb: 50-75% of COIs Don't Match the Lease
A Senior Vice President at a major commercial insurance brokerage recently told us "every property manager I work with is sitting on a ticking time bomb of coverage gaps." He wasn't being dramatic. He was naming a quiet crisis in commercial real estate that most PMs don't see until a claim hits. Across the commercial portfolios we've analyzed, the pattern is consistent: between 50-75% of tenant Certificates of Insurance fail compliance verification when checked against actual lease requirements. The tracker says compliant. The lease says something different. The owner is exposed.
David Bunch
COI Basics
Mar 10, 2026
Your COI Spreadsheet Says "Current." Your Lease Says Otherwise.
Most commercial property managers believe they have COI compliance handled. They track expirations. They follow up when a policy lapses. They keep a spreadsheet or maybe a platform that shows green checkmarks next to tenant names. And every time they look at that spreadsheet, they feel a little better about their risk exposure. That confidence is misplaced. Here's why
David Bunch
COI Basics
Oct 3, 2025
Slip-and-Fall Liability is Quietly Crushing NOI: What Multifamily Owners Need to Know (and Do) Before Winter Starts
Winter is coming, and for multifamily owners, “slip-and-fall season” is no joke. What once might have been a modest claim (say, $40–$60K) is now routinely pushing into six figures, and even jury verdicts in the millions are showing up. Couple that with insurance premiums rising at rates many haven’t seen before, and you’ve got a serious threat to NOI, asset value, and insurability. If you manage, invest in, or insure multifamily property, it's time to see slip-and-fall risk not as a liability footnote, but as a core financial exposure.
David Bunch